SCOTUS Rules AGAINST EPA in Major Clean Waters Decision

U.S. SUPREME COURT RULES AGAINST EPA IN WETLANDS REGULATION CHALLENGE


By John Kruzel and Nate Raymond, Agriculture.com, May 25, 2023
 

May 25 (Reuters) - The U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday put another dent in the regulatory reach of the Environmental Protection Agency, ruling in favor of an Idaho couple in their long-running bid to build a home on property that the EPA had deemed a protected wetland under a landmark federal anti-pollution law.

The justices in a 9-0 decision overturned a lower court's ruling against the couple, Chantell and Mike Sackett, that had upheld the EPA's determination that their property near a lake contained wetlands protected by the Clean Water Act of 1972. Though the justices unanimously agreed to reverse the lower court's decision, they differed in their reasoning for doing so.

The ruling marked the latest instance of the court backing a challenge to the scope of the EPA's ability to regulate in the environmental arena under existing law. In a 6-3 ruling last June powered by its conservative justices, the court imposed limits on the EPA's authority to issue sweeping regulations involving greenhouse gas emissions from existing coal- and gas-fired power plants under a different environmental law, the Clean Air Act.

The case decided on Thursday stemmed from the Sacketts' purchase in 2004 of an undeveloped plot of land about 300 feet (90 meters) from Priest Lake, one of the largest lakes in Idaho, near the U.S.-Canada border. In 2007, the couple began preparing construction of a home on it.

But after placing sand and gravel fill on the lot, the EPA issued an administrative compliance order stating the property contained wetlands protected by the Clean Water Act and that they needed a permit to build, which they had failed to obtain.

That law bars discharging pollutants, including rocks and sand, into the "waters of the United States," which regulators for decades have said covers not just navigable waters but adjacent wetlands like swamps, marshes and berms.
 

CLICK HERE TO READ MORE AT AGRICULTURE.COM


 


 
SCOTUS Rules AGAINST EPA by Tom Zawistowski is licensed under

New Podcast Posted Every Week!

Watch ANY ARCHIVE of the We the People Convention Podcast by clicking on "PLAYLIST".

Recent News

Biden Forced Out of Presidential Race
Biden Forced Out of Presidential Race

Biden drops out of presidential race after Democratic revolt following disastrous debate

READ MORE

Burgess Owens Pushing Chevron Sunset Act
Burgess Owens Pushing Chevron Sunset Act

Rep. Burgess Owens is co-sponsoring a bill that could put lots of federal regulations on the chopping block

READ MORE

Latest Video

J.D. Vance RNC Acceptance Speech 7-17-24
J.D. Vance RNC Acceptance Speech 7-17-24

Senator J.D. Vance Accepts the Nomination of the RNC to be Vice-President

WATCH NOW

©2024, We the People Convention